Miami Beach commission runoff: Two women, one seat — and the city’s future

If you thought the 2025 Miami Beach election season was all settled after Nov. 4, think again. Because there’s still one seat up in the air — one commissioner’s seat, one citywide vote, and two women each claiming they’ll save the soul of the Beach.
Monica Matteo‑Salinas , a longtime city staffer who worked for two commissioners, and Monique Pardo Pope , a MAGA-loving attorney and daughter of a convicted and state executed serial killer, came out on top of a crowded six-person field for the Group I seat vacated by termed-out commissioner Kristen Rosen Gonzalez, who lost a challenge (barely) to Mayor Steven Meiner. And now they’re headed to a runoff on Dec. 9.
Matteo-Salinas, 46, came out with a small edge, 23% of the vote compared to 20% for Pardo Pope. She is the “residents first” candidate, pitching affordability (a community food pantry for those in need), transportation — advertising can help subsidize an expanded trolley system — and “restrained development,” which is another way to say development. She served as an aide to both Commissioners Rosen Gonzalez and Alex Fernandez, who won his re-election handily, and also served as the chair of the nonprofit Miami Beach Community Development Corporation, a group focused on affordable-housing issues.
Read related: Miami Beach commission races give us two incumbents, one dramatic runoff
The single mom of two boys at Miami Beach High — involved in the PTA since they were at South Pointe Elementary — is leaning into the backlash against overdevelopment and displacement and tapping into that growing frustration that Miami Beach is morphing into a glossy playground for outsiders while longtime residents, from service workers to families, get squeezed out. Her focus on affordability, food-security, keeping noise and size of new towers in check resonates hard.
Matteo-Salinas has the endorsement of Fernandez and Commissioner Laura Dominguez, who also won re-election Nov. 4, as well as Mami-Dade Mayor Daniella Levine Cava, the Miami Beach Fraternal Order of Police and SOBESAFE, an organization of volunteers that focus on issues of crime and code enforcement, whose board cited her “combination of relevant, insider experience on how to get things done with a resident’s desire to get them done better.”
Pardo Pope, 44, finished only three points behind, close enough to make every subsequent attack ad, whisper campaign, and voter-turnout push matter. She is a family-law attorney, with a beachside office, and used to work in finance. She leads the nonprofit Woman’s Cancer Association of the University of Miami and emphasizes public safety in her campaign. She has positioned herself as the “law and order” candidate, vowing to combat homeless camping, protect infrastructure, and partner with developers — but on her terms. For voters nervous about property crime, transient populations, and overtaxed city services, that’s a clear message.
But, still, Matteo Salinas did get the FOP nod. “She knows that keeping Miami Beach safe takes trust and teamwork between officers, residents, and City Hall,” said FOP President Bobby Hernandez. “Monica brings the kind of practical leadership and integrity our city needs.”
Pardo Pope says she is also for “smart growth,” but is endorsed by Commissioner David Suarez, who has proposed a huge density increase along almost al of Washington Avenue that would allow more than 2,000 new units to be built. Is that smart development?
Pardo Pope is also sort of a MAGA groupie who posts social media photos with Republican legislators, including Sen. Rick Scott, who signed her father’s death warrant when he was Florida governor and her papi was on death row.
Oh, yeah, in case you didn’t know: Pardo Pope is the daughter of a Hitler-loving serial killer sentenced to death by lethal injection.
Manuel Pardo was a Sweetwater cop-turned-vigilante who fatally shot nine people in three months back in 1986. He idolized Hitler, kept Nazi trinkets in his Hialeah apartment, tattooed his Doberman with a swastika, and told the court the only thing he regretted was that he didn’t kill 99 people instead of nine drug dealers for money and cocaine. Some say Manuel Pardo may have been the inspiration for the series Dexter, about a Florida medical examiner who becomes a vigilante serial killer.
Read related: Miami Beach commission candidate is daughter of cop-turned-serial-killer
Pardo Pope and her supporters say that shouldn’t matter. She can’t be accountable for her father’s crime. She was a child.
But she calls him her “hero” in her social media posts and it’s hard to ignore the Hitler-loving murderer details in a town with a large Jewish population. She is also tied to the Christian Family Coalition — an organization that hates women, gays and good books. Because, hey, let’s just offend everybody.
It’s also hard to ignore the partisanship in this race.
The Miami Beach commission races — like the county and the city of Miami races — are technically nonpartisan, but the MAGA presence in Republican Pardo Pope’s social media and messaging has been pretty obvious and that has turned this into a mini partisan war. Pardo Pope is a member of the Republican National Lawyers Association and has served as a Miami-Dade Republican Executive Committeewoman. Matteo-Salinas is a registered Democrat.
While the ballot doesn’t list party labels, the battle lines are political in every sense: home-town charm vs. “law & order,” progressive-leaning residents vs. conservative property owners and renters. This runoff may serve as a micro-test of where Miami Beach stands after a year of statewide conservative governance.
What’s at stake is important. Unless there’s a surprise rally, the three incumbents — plus the future winner in this race — will shape the next four years. That one seat could tilt big decisions on development, police enforcement, homelessness, and beach-front zoning. Real estate interests and developer money are sniffing around, and the outcome might decide who controls the fate of neighborhoods already stretched thin by tourism and luxury condos.
Both women have raised about the same amount of funds for their campaigns, according to the most recent finance reports filed with the city. Matteo-Salinas has collected $83,642, with many small donations from Miami Beach residents, but also including $25,000 of her own money. Pardo Pope has raised $94,064, including maximum $1,000 checks from former Commissioners Ricky Arriola and Jonah Wolfson and $38,000 loaned to herself. Pardo Pope has also provided $15,180 in in-kind contributions to her own campaign. So, that’s a $53,000 investment in getting elected.
Early voting starts next next Friday — conveniently overlapping with Art Basel weekend, when tens of thousands descend on Miami Beach. As the city swells with international art fans and tourists, locals who care about who represents them will need to fight crowds to get to the polls — or vote by mail.
Miami Beach voters — especially those who are not million-dollar investors — better not sit this out.
Because once the choice is made on Dec. 9, they won’t get another shot for four years.

You can help get more independent, watchdog government reporting of our local government and political campaigns to our community with a contribution to Political Cortadito. Click here. Ladra thanks you for your support.

The post Miami Beach commission runoff: Two women, one seat — and the city’s future appeared first on Political Cortadito.

Read Full Story