Miami Mayor Francis Suarez made a rare appearance at the city commission meeting last week to push for the return of $20 million to developers of Miami Freedom Park — the boondoggle real estate complex with a soccer stadium in the mix that is being built on the grounds of the old Melreese golf course — even though he tried to make it look like that was always the plan.
Suarez said the $20 million, which the public thought were going to the improvement and acquisition of other parks in the city, were always supposed to go to the maintenance of the 58-acre park, which on the MFP website is called Jorge Mas Canosa Park. He said the “language was very clear” in the 2018 ballot question passed by 60% of the voters in 2018 “that $20 million was going to go to a 58-acre park,” he paused for dramatic effect, “or other green space.”
Key words: Other green space.
But Suarez said that those three little words were only included because it was a constitutional question, which meant that it would dictate what the city could and could not do based on what people voted for. “And you want some legal room in case you want to deviate from what the voters themselves wanted,” the mayor explained.
Did he mean legal wiggle room? So this was intentional? Someone knew all along that the $20 million — sold as a public benefit to sweeten the deal for residents — would never go to “other green space?”
Read related: Miami Freedom Park developers want their $20 million parks donation back
The idea, when the 99-year lease agreement was approved in 2022, was spurred by the “no net loss” policy that meant the loss of green space at Melreese would have to be replaced elsewhere, Suarez said. Because of that policy, the city carved out $7.5 million from the $20 mil to give $2.5 mil to commission districts 2, 3 and 5 for the acquisition and development of new parks, he said. District 4 was punished because Commissioner Manolo Reyes always voted against Miami Freedom Park. District 1 was left out because that’s where Miami Freedom Park is.

“Four months later, the property was rezoned, the no net loss issue was resolved,” Suarez said. “That money should be restored based on what the voters want, or the will of the voters.
“This is a city park that the residents voted in favor of allocating $20 millions to,” he said, forgetting the words “other green space,” this time, and reminding everyone that $20 million today are not the same as 2018 dollars.
“It’s like giving The Underline a haircut.”
To sell it (this time) to commissioners, Suarez sweetened the soured deal with an amendment that would allocate $2.5 million to districts 2, 3 and 5 and basically instructed the city manager to find the funds by April. “So that no resident in the city can say that they, in any way, feel disenfranchised.” It was expanded to $10 million — with another $2.5 mil for District 4 — after Commissioner Joe Carollo volunteered to help the manager find the funds.
“I believe I can find the funds for the three districts, because one was getting more, and find sufficient funds to give commissioner Reyes his $2.5 million also for his district,” said Carollo, who should be investigated for how he spent the millions in funds budgeted by the Bayfront Park Management Trust when he was chair for eight years.
“I will work with the manager and I will show him fairly quickly where the money can be found.”
Shudder.
Carollo blasted the media for “so much disinformation out there” and said the city would have had to spend the money to maintain the 58-acre park anyway.
“At no time have we been speaking about the Mas brothers not going to pay us the $20 million, that they are going to somehow do a switch and bait and use the dollars for their park,” Carollo said, referring to Jorge and Jose Mas, who own the Inter Miami team with David Beckham and are developing the property. Well, that’s kind of what happened.

The bottom line is that the commission voted 4-1 to return the full $20 million into a fund to maintain the park at the soccer stadium complex — which will also have offices, restaurants, stores and a 700-room hotel. Only Commissioner Damian Pardo voted against it, but he told Political Cortadito after the meeting that the did so because he did not have enough time to digest what was being proposed.
Reyes voted in favor because he said the resolution was “respecting the will of the people.” But he voted against another resolution that supported the establishment of a Community Development District, which is an  instrument to collect maintenance fees. Basically, the developers are going to tax themselves — as the only “property owners” — to create an avenue for $500,000 to be earmarked for maintenance of the park for the next 100 years.
Read related: Miami Freedom Park scores yes vote for massive stadium real estate complex
CDDs are typically formed where there are residential owners who can leverage the future tax dollars to borrow on a tax-exempt basis. But because this is a wholly commercial development, with no resident board (at least for now), the developers of Miami Freedom Park won’t be able to do that, Suarez explained. “In this case there is no allowance for housing, because it’s next to the airport, so they can’t borrow on a tax-free basis.”
But, apparently, they can still borrow funds, because the mayor said there was another safety net.
“If they defaulted if they did borrow funds, CDDs do not impact the city in terms of, its not a lien against the city property,” Suarez said. “It would be a lien against the lease hold interest.” He said the tenants requested that the city support their application to become a CDD, which is through the county, because “they want to contribute to the operation and maintenance of the park.”
Okay. But why do they need a CDD to do that? Are they really just trying to borrow money with the lease as collateral?
Suarez stressed all the positives, calling it the best “stadium deal in the world.” He reminded the commission about the $5 million the developers are giving to the Baywalk along Biscayne Bay and the Miami River. Though Ladra thinks they would take that back if there was waterfront at the development site.
He said the $20 million are to shore up the fund because the $500,000 produced by the CDD won’t be enough.
“They want to make sure the the park, which is adjacent to their property, is kept up and maintained,” Suarez said. They didn’t want to leave it up to the city, he said, which “could have years when it maintains it well and years when it maintains it poorly.”
“They want to be able to control that outcome… have the park up to the billion dollar standard that is going up next door.”
“So, this is found money,” Suarez said. “This is money they didn’t have to pay so it’s just going to make the deal better than what it was.”
But what is $20 million in a $1 billion project? Is someone going to argue that the developers — who obviously need better public relations representation — don’t have another $20 million somewhere that they could have used for that? They had to take what amounts to $7.5 million from the city’s taxpayers — because the city manager is going to find that somewhere to fill the hole made by this resolution — to make themselves feel better?
If you like what you read in Political Cortadito, consider making a contribution to independent watchdog journalism. Show your support with a one-time or recurring donation. And thank you!
The post Miami Freedom Park gets its full $20 million back for 58-acre public park appeared first on Political Cortadito.

Read Full Story

It took a lawsuit against him for abusing his power, but Miami Commissioner Joe Carollo was finally stripped of his post as chairman of the Bayfront Park Management Trust, which he has been leading for almost eight years. This comes a month after a whistleblower lawsuit from two former employees who say that Carollo used the Trust as his own personal slush fund.
Commissioners voted 3-2 Thursday — only Chairwoman Christine King sided with Crazy Joe — to remove Carollo as chair. They also replaced him with Commissioner Miguel Gabela, who led the effort to oust him.
“I know you’ve done some good things in the park,” Gabela had told Carollo. “But things have gotten out of hand.”
Carollo and the city were sued last month by former Trust Executive Director Jose Suarez and former Finance Director Jose Canto, who say they were forced to resign after they reported shoddy accounting practices that allowed Carollo to giveaway contracts to his friends and get kickbacks from them. They also said that Carollo used the funds raised by the agency, which oversees both Bayfront and Maurice Ferre parks, to fund his own office events and promote his political profile.
Read related: Miami Joe Carollo Bayfront scandal snares Coral Gables pal Javier Baños
While King said that the commission had already scheduled new board chair appointments for the March meeting, and she didn’t mind waiting, Gabela said the recent news gave the removal a sense of urgency. Commissioner Manolo Reyes agreed.
“It’s about time we stop it, so we don’t get any more black eyes,” Reyes said.

Despite having promised last year to step down in January, Carollo defended his stewardship and called a visibly uncomfortable Chief Financial Officer and Assistant City Manager Larry Spring to the podium help him justify himself, pointing to annual audits and emails that show Commissioner Damian Pardo had also asked questions about the Trust’s funding. Wow. The commissioner in the district of the two parks that the Trust oversees — Bayfront Park and Maurice Ferre Park — dared to asked questions about operations and expenditures? You gotta be kidding.
They should all have been asking questions.
Of course, Carollo used his mic to attack everyone else.
“One of the worst things in life is to be so successful at something, they kill you for it,” he said, WHAT, saying the ouster was motivated by “envy.” No, it was motivated by good common sense.
He reserved his most pointed remarks for Gabela, again, hinting that the District 1 commissioner had made a mistake going after”a guy who was really your biggest supporter here for Allapattah.”
King asked for the commissioner to keep his comments short and non-confrontational. “You want to have a kangaroo court,” he shouted at her and demanded to have his say “if I’m going to be thrown in the dirt by so-called colleagues.”
Read related: Miami Commissioner Joe Carollo wants old lackey to lead Bayfront Park Trust
Carollo said he had every intention of stepping down in January and it’s why he rushed to finish the Bayfront fountain project.”It wa you who was here and Mr. Pardo by Zoom who voted to bring all the boards to the March 13 meeting,” he told Gabela
At that point, King was so frustrated that she called for a pee-pee break. “You know what? I have to go to the bathroom,” she said. “This meeting is in recess.”
But when she came back, it did not get better.
Carollo continued with the emails he said showed that Pardo’s office wanted a formal investigation into the inventory, and specifically the controlled substances, in a veterinarian trailer that the Trust had overpaid for by tens of thousands of dollars. “This is all behind the city manager’s back, going direct to police.
“Mr. Pardo abused his power. Mr. Pardo abused his office… by going directly to the police chief and falsely claim he had anonymous complaints and people coming up to him at meetings.

“Mr. Gabela went to the radio, the Miami Herald, to put my face in the dirt, to try to humiliate me,” Carollo said, tone deaf to the fact that he doesn’t need anybody to humiliate him since he does such a good job himself.
Carollo said that his enemies, the Little Havana businessmen who won a federal First Amendment lawsuit against him and former State Rep. Manuel “Manny” Prieguez, who the commissioner pointed to in the audience — who was laughing out loud — were behind the effort to oust him. He said Prieguez represents a company that wants to put events on at Bayfront Park.
“His handlers got a hold of him right away and told him what to do,” Carollo said about Gabela.
Gabela shot back: “The only person that handles me is my wife.”
Read related: Joe Carollo wants to abolish Miami’s Bayfront Park Management Trust
He called the question three or four times before they actually voted because Carollo went on and on about the war against him.
Gabela has been trying to remove Carollo from the Trust since at least last June. Guess he needed the controversy of a whistleblower lawsuit alleging mismanagement of funds to get it done.
“You’re problem is you’re like Maduro,” Gabela said, comparing Carollo to the Venezuelan dictator. “You don’t want to leave.”
In the end, Carollo said he did not have time for the Bayfront Trust and wanted to give it up — just not to Gabela, who he said wanted the chairmanship “for all the wrong reasons.”
In related news, there was no appetite, as Commissioner Carollo noted, to abolish the Bayfront Trust and, before the chairmanship vote, he voted along with the rest of the commission to unanimously reject the his own measure.
He should have given the chairmanship up then.
The post Miami Commissioner Joe Carollo loses Bayfront Park Trust to Miguel Gabela appeared first on Political Cortadito.

Read Full Story

Before Hialeah Mayor Esteban “Steve” Bovo steps down to take a job at a Washington, D.C., lobbying firm, he voted Tuesday to give himself retirement benefits.
Ladra was still trying to get details on what the deferred compensation plan for electeds would look like, because there was zero discussion or debate about the two ordinances on the dais before everyone voted in favor of giving themselves more free money. But there were no official answers as of Friday afternoon.
According to sources close to City Hall, council members will be vested after five years of service, but the mayor is vested from Day One. It’s also retroactive to October 21, 2021.
Ladra was unable to get more details after several emails to the city clerk and calls to Bovo went unanswered and unreturned.
Read related: Hialeah Mayor Esteban Bovo posts extreme views, promotes ‘big lie’
There will still have to be a second reading Feb. 25 before it’s final.
It’s not exactly a pension, per se. Voters in Hialeah did away with pensions for elected officials in 2013 with 80% approving a charter amendment.  Before that, electeds got a pension after they reached the age of 55 and completed 12 years or more of service on the council. It also required any future changes to the pension plans of elected officials to be approved by a city-wide vote.
It did not wipe out the pensions that were already granted. According to Ballotpedia, former Mayor Raul Martinez gets a pension of $180,000 a year and former Mayor Carlos “Castro” Hernandez gets around $190,000 a year.

Bovo, who makes $190,000 a year in salary and expenses, will be leaving his post to join The Southern Group, a prominent lobbying outfit in D.C., according to the Miami Herald, which reported it last week. His compensation is reportedly going to be higher, but he still felt the need to take a little more from Hialeah taxpayers.
It’s likely that a majority of Hialeah residents don’t have pensions. This population’s average household income was $53,000 a year in 2023, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. That’s household. Individual average salary was at about $25,800. The Census also said that 17.5% of Hialeah’s residents are living at or below the poverty level.
Remember when Miami Commissioner Miguel Gabela pulled the same thing with granting lifetime pensions in his city and got pummeled for it on the radio and in the news? The backlash from the community caused him to want to put an item to reconsider o the agenda. But Mayor Francis Suarez got there first with a veto and was hailed as a hero.
Read related: Bryan Calvo becomes first candidate to file for November Hialeah mayor’s race
But in Hialeah, so far? Crickets.
And here we have a mayor who has one foot out the door, voting on extending his benefits before he does.
Former Councilmember Bryan Calvo, who resigned to run for tax collector (lost in the primary), is now running for mayor in November to replace Bovo and said he would undo the golden parachute as soon as possible if given the chance.
“The pension proposals are a total slap in the face to residents and father proof that Bovo and company are more concerned about extracting every possible cent from the tax payer than public service,” Calvo told Political Cortadito. “For both items to be approved unanimously and without any discussion on the dais is proof that the fix was in for Bovo to make a final cash out before his departure and to setup his heir apparent for a comfortable transition.
“If elected, I will absolutely repeal said ordinances,” said Calvo, who sued Bovo in 2023 for abuse of power after the mayor allegedly hampered his efforts to get 911 information. The lawsuit was dismissed in court last year.
Ladra smells a campaign issue.
The post Steve Bovo’s parting gift: Retirement benefits for himself, Hialeah electeds appeared first on Political Cortadito.

Read Full Story

It may not be a general or mid-term election year, but several cities in Miami-Dade have important elections that can impact the lives of their residents for years to come. The biggest are in Miami and Hialeah, where mayoral contests will be wide open, and Miami Beach and Homestead. Those four are in November.
There are also other elections in smaller municipalities scattered throughout the year with different qualifying periods.
The first two elections in Miami-Dade for 2025 were cancelled.
In Golden Beach, Mayor Glenn Singer and Councilmember Judy Lusskin were re-elected without opposition. Newly elected Councilmember Jessie Mendal, who is filling the seat vacated by Jaime Mendal, who served for eight years, was elected without any opposition. In Hialeah Gardens, Mayor Yioset de la Cruz and two council members — Group 5 and Group 6, but the website doesn’t say who is which group — were also re-elected with no opposition. Which is predictable in these tiny towns.
Read related: Long list of potential 2025 Miami mayoral candidates starts to take form
There could be an election in Bay Harbor Islands, where there are two candidates in one of the council races, so far. And in Miami Springs, where there is some movement based on term limits and personal reasons leaving an open mayoral and three open council seats. Both of those are April 1, but qualifying doesn’t end until Feb. 20 and Feb. 14, respectively.

There is also a special election in Surfside on April 1, where voters will be asked if the charter should be amended to limit the floor area ratio to a maximum 0.50 for new detached single family homes in the H30A and H30B districts. That’s basically half the size of the lot area. The only exception would be made after a unanimous approval from the commission and a 60% vote of the public.
Floor area ratio (FAR) is the measurement of a building’s floor area in relation to the size of the lot/parcel. FAR is expressed as a decimal, derived by dividing the total area of the building by the total area of the parcel. Higher FARs indicate greater building volume. FAR is most often used to express development intensity and has spurred much debate at several municipal zoning meetings.
The first highly-anticipated and contentious election is in Coral Gables on April 8. The truly contested mayoral race is expected to be dirty and full of lies, as Mayor Vince Lago defends his position to a challenge from Commissioner Kirk Menendez. Vice Mayor Rhonda Anderson is also up for re-election and is facing a challenge from Felix Pardo and Laureano Cancio. The open seat vacated by Menendez will see a contest between attorney Richard Lara, the handpicked and groomed Lago candidate, FreeBee lobbyist Claudia Miro, who lost a commission race in 2021, and attorney Tom Wells.
Read related: Two more candidates say they will run for Coral Gables commission in April
The Lago/Anderson/Lara slate is being cast as the pro-development, anti-resident ticket. But Lago’s pull is questionable. He was unopposed two years ago but supported two commission candidates who lost. Shortly after that, he lost the majority. Lara is his attempt to get it back. If he and Anderson win, but Lara loses, Lago will still be as paralyzed by the 3-2 vote as he is now.
April 8 is also the date for the Miami Shores election and the special election to fill a vacant commission seat in Biscayne Park.
In May, voters in Sweetwater have an election scheduled for commissioners in Groups 1, 2, 3 and 4. City Clerk Carmen Garcia told Political Cortadito that nobody has registered yet. The deadline to qualify is March 28.
Of course, the big races are in November, and Ladra will have independent stories on each of those as the campaigns roll out.
A relatively new Florida law requires all vote-by-mail ballot requests to be purged after every general and midterm election. But the county elections department has been sending out emails and text messages to get traditional absentee ballot voters to make their requests. As of Wednesday, since 19,113 have requested a vote-by-mail ballot since Jan. 1 of this year, according to the Miami-Dade Elections Department.
To request an absentee ballot for an election in any of these cities, visit the county elections department’s page.
The post Miami-Dade 2025 election calendar starts with cancelled races, April ballots appeared first on Political Cortadito.

Read Full Story

The newly-restored and functional water fountain at Bayfront Park was on full display for New Year’s Eve. At least in the commercials played that night on the America Tevé broadcast of the party. But this week is the official ribbon-cutting.
There will be a press conference at 6 p.m. Wednesday with Mayor Francis Suarez and District 3 Commissioner Joe Carollo, who is chairman of the Bayfront Park Management Trust. This is happening one day, less than 24 hours, before Carollo proposes the abolishment of the Bayfront Trust and on the heels of accusations that he has been using the agency as a slush fund for favors to his pals and kickbacks.
Que cara mas dura.
Read related: Joe Carollo wants to abolish Miami’s Bayfront Park Management Trust
Carollo and the city have been sued by two former Management Trust employees who say the were threatened and forced to resign after they reported shoddy accounting practices led to widespread misuse of Trust funds. The lack of proper accounting procedures “enabled Carollo to (a) use the Trust’s funds to pay for Carollo’s own political ventures; (b) use the Trust’s funds to support Carollo’s District 3 Political Office (c) use the Trust’s funds to pay and overpay Carollo’s political allies; (d) use the Trust’s funds to overpay Carollo’s District 3 Social Media provider, (e) waste the Trust’s funds on a 2007 Vet mobile that was never used and that had a suspicious and seemingly untraceable past; and e) seek to use the Trust funds to pay for Carollo’s Holiday Party,” the complaint, filed by former executive director Jose Suarez and former financial director Jose Canto, states.
“Together, these wrongful expenditures totaled hundreds of thousands of dollars of misused and wasted Trust funds in less than one year, and Carollo has Chaired the Trust for the past eight years without any legitimate oversight.”
But, hey, we got a fountain.
Read related: Miami paid $150K for one long Joe Carollo commercial on New Year’s Eve
The Mildred and Claude Pepper Fountain at Bayfront Park, built in 1990, had been dry for longer than it was working. The city stopped operating it little by little because of costs and then it became the base for some balloon vendor. Last summer, the Trust began a renovation project that cost $5.5 million and, while the original design created by Japanese-American architect Isamu Noguchi has been preserved, they have added 500 lights and 800 jet streams and a “water screen” that projects videos and images.

“Seeing that fountain light up, other than the births of my children and my marriage, is one of the happiest moments of my life,” Suarez said last month during the State of the City address. Obviously, he’s had a dour life. And he needs to get out more.
The Trust’s interim executive director, Barbara Hernandez, told Axios Miami that the fountain is “still in the testing stage” and that the Trust is “working on a schedule for show times.” She also said that the cost to operate and maintain the fountain is between $20,000 and $30,000 a month. That’s between $240,000 and $360,000 a year.
Maybe they should seek a sponsor.
The post Miami Commissioner Joe Carollo and the Bayfront Fountain of corruption appeared first on Political Cortadito.

Read Full Story

The developers of Miami Freedom Park, that real estate complex that comes with a soccer stadium on the grounds of what once was the Melreese Golf Course, want to get out of the $20 million they once promised to spend upgrading and enhancing city parks as part of its sweet deal approved in 2022.
And they got Mayor Francis Suarez to do their dirty work.
Suarez has proposed the establishment of a new special revenue account titled “Park Fund for Miami Freedom Park,” that would use allocated funds exclusively for improvements and maintenance of the 58 acre pubic park” that is part of the complex to be developed by Miami Freedom Park, LLC, which is basically David Beckham and brothers Jorge and Jose Mas, who also own the Inter Miami team. The city said that MFP has already made the first of two $10 million payments for this new special account.
Oh, so special.
Suarez is going to ask Miami Commissioners to let MFP off the hook at Thursday’s meeting. This comes about month after the city put the developers on notice for not paying the second half of their promised park funding and withheld the master permit for the site of the $1 billion development, a retail and office park with restaurants, a 750-room hotel and, oh yeah, a 25,000-seat stadium that will host games for the Inter Miami team.
Read related: Miami Freedom Park scores yes vote for massive stadium real estate complex
This is a bait and switch. Because the development agreement reached in April 2022 in a historic vote for a 99-year lease stipulated that the developers would donate $20 million to be used “for improvements to public parks or acquisition of public parks within the city of Miami.” Not for Miami Freedom Park, but other parks citywide. Commissioner Joe Carollo asked for that. Of the $25 million given to the city in exchange for the pleasure of developing the property and making millions of dollars, $20 million would go to city parks and $5 million would go to the Baywalk on the Miami River and Biscayne Bay.
At least that is what everybody thought. These were even campaign promises made for the referendum vote in 2018 where voters gave the city the green light to begin negotiations. These park improvement funds were one of the alleged public benefits.
Now the $20 million is going to their own project?

What’s next? Maybe they don’t want to make the park 58 acres. Maybe it’s good enough at 35 acres.
Maybe they won’t create 15,000 “direct or indirect jobs” (minus the dozen lobbyists) or the 2,000 permanent jobs that were promised. That was just a ballpark figure.
Maybe they won’t be able to pay the $4.3 million in annual guaranteed rent. I mean, the economy, right?
Read related: Marlins Park’s David Samson: Miami Freedom Park is a ‘billion dollar heist’
These were some of the other things that were promised when the Miami Freedom Park developers were trying to get the deal. They even said they would bear all the costs of maintaining the roads, lights, sidewalks and benches at the new 58-acre park it would pay to build. Now they want their $20 million back to do it.
Back then, Jorge Mas said there was  “no public subsidy” — even though developers did get an $8 million state grant for infrastructure last year.
“There is significant economic benefit from tax revenue and new jobs,” Mas said at the April 2022 meeting “And I have to deliver the public benefits first.”
Before or after he takes back the $20 million he promised?
The post Miami Freedom Park developers want their $20 million parks donation back appeared first on Political Cortadito.

Read Full Story